HP Character-Off (Twilight vs. Harry Potter)
This is my opinion and if you have a diffrent one please express it, but don't slander my own. Thank you.
-Skye
Ok here I want to talk about the "girls" in Harrys life. Not really. More like how people think Cho is some girly girl and and sl/ut who will cry if she doesn't get what she wants.
In the books she is sorta wimpy but she isn't a sl/ut, but in the books I like Ginny a WHOLE lot more than her.
Ginny is tough nuggets, smart, and got swag.
The way Ginnys character is wrote in the book is genius. Starts out as sorta of the shy, weird girl who giggles alot. And then BAM!
she kicks as.s
But in the movies, I like Cho better than Ginny. For the record, in the fifth movie, Cho is forced to sell out the DA, because of Umbridge.
In the books it's her idiot friend. So really in the movies she is cool. She isn't a sl/ut and is pretty nice, and quite.
I absolutely dislike Ginny in the movies. When you think about it, Ginny cheats on Dean.
In the sixth movie, she kisses Harry in the Room of Requirment, and she HASN'T BROKEN UP WITH DEAN YET!!!
HOLD UP!
So....what does that tell you?? AND in the seventh movie she is such an awkward flirt!!!
She goes to Harry with her dress zipped down to her as.s and is like, "zip me up.". Euww.
Plus she isn't wearing a bra, or either has chicken boobs.
Amen to George Weasly who breaks that little nonsense up.
My point is that in the books Ginny is a strong women who doesn't back down and is loyal.
In the movies, I feel like they didn't make Ginny as good as she could of been. They made her worse.
-Skye
In the books she is sorta wimpy but she isn't a sl/ut, but in the books I like Ginny a WHOLE lot more than her.
Ginny is tough nuggets, smart, and got swag.
The way Ginnys character is wrote in the book is genius. Starts out as sorta of the shy, weird girl who giggles alot. And then BAM!
she kicks as.s
But in the movies, I like Cho better than Ginny. For the record, in the fifth movie, Cho is forced to sell out the DA, because of Umbridge.
In the books it's her idiot friend. So really in the movies she is cool. She isn't a sl/ut and is pretty nice, and quite.
I absolutely dislike Ginny in the movies. When you think about it, Ginny cheats on Dean.
In the sixth movie, she kisses Harry in the Room of Requirment, and she HASN'T BROKEN UP WITH DEAN YET!!!
HOLD UP!
So....what does that tell you?? AND in the seventh movie she is such an awkward flirt!!!
She goes to Harry with her dress zipped down to her as.s and is like, "zip me up.". Euww.
Plus she isn't wearing a bra, or either has chicken boobs.
Amen to George Weasly who breaks that little nonsense up.
My point is that in the books Ginny is a strong women who doesn't back down and is loyal.
In the movies, I feel like they didn't make Ginny as good as she could of been. They made her worse.
-Skye
uibblo Membership is FREE!
80 Comments
Please login or register to submit your comment.
I read a Sign up for a group story before, and it was some sort of a fandom war. So one girl posted her entry, for being a Potterhead. One thing you had to fill out was: A Characteristic You Need For This Fandom:, or something like that. And the girl put "Hates Twilight" as one of them. And I've met plenty of Potterhead's who like Twilight, sorry just kind of wanted to tell someone about that.
For some reason, I didn't really notice the fact that Ginny could've still been with Dean while she kissed Harry. Rupert wasn't too er, what I expected at the start, but yeah, at least seemed to have gotten better at the end of the HP movies. Fred used to be my favourite, in the first and second books, but then he sort of took control. I missed the sentences that had a "George said" in them. I haven't read Twilight, but I think you have a point, something that made me kinda mad before was that
I'm afraid I'll have to agree with harrypottersbiggestfan on this - I didn't agree with any of this, and I thought your points were rather weak. The entire thing wasn't very well written in general.
But everyone has opinions, this is mine, and I admire you for just putting your thoughts out there. It just so happens on these particular subjects, our opinions don't exactly go hand in hand :)
Agree to disagree(: thanks for your output though.
no hate,but this was not my favorite work of yours. i disagreed with most of that. but everyone has an opinion and this is mine.i love your other stuff tho.
I value your opinion so thanks. What other stuff?
thank you for that!
no offence, and i know i have commented twice, but it seems like u don't completely get the films...
plz don't take this the bad way, cause from what it sounds like..
its just my opinion
i dont take it offense, u have your opinion and i have mine
hey, thats offensive, ginnys awesome, so plz don't say those things about her, shes a person u know!!!
soz if u find this message weird!!!
i'm a Harry Potter fan all the way!
honestly I dont like Twilight. I think its stupid. call me a hater or stupid or whatever, but that's just my opinion.
I also hate Percy Jackson. :P
Not really about Twilight/Harry Potter argument.....but I thought the Percy Jackson movie was brilliant, and I really hope they do another. I didn't like the books at all--cute, but not worth my time. Making the characters older made the whole thing work for me, and while people didn't all look like they were supposed to, the movie was the best thing that happened to that series.
ehh i guess but since i really liked the books the movie was just so different from the books they didn't mention Clarisse, Hades wasn't the bad guy even though in the movie he was, and the characters where off. btw do u think luke was on crack or what? haha